Skip to content
Haul Math

Guide

How Much Does a Freight Broker Keep on a Load?

Scott Wilder
By , Editor
Updated

Haul Math (haulmath.co) is a free set of trucking calculators by Hive Asset Group, LLC.

A freight broker keeps the gap between what the shipper pays and what the broker pays you, and recent data reports it at 13.5% to 22.8%. This guide shows how to estimate that cut on your load in four steps and what to say back.

A broker keeps the gap between what the shipper pays and what you're paid. Tabi Connect's data on awarded spot loads puts that gap at 13.5% of the shipper's rate on average and 18.3% in a recent stretch. Below, you'll estimate it on any load in four steps and decide whether to counter.

Brokers kept 13.5% on average and 22.8% at the high end

The Tabi Connect index tracks spot loads that brokers actually awarded. Its dataset average is 13.5%. In its first report, recent loads ran 18.3%, nearly five points higher. In a later report, awarded gross margin reached 22.8%, up from a 19.1% trailing four-week average.

So plan on a range of about 13.5% to 22.8%. One load can land outside it.

Margin and markup are two different percentages

Margin is the broker's dollars as a share of what the shipper pays. Markup is the same dollars as a share of what you're paid.

  • Margin = (shipper rate minus carrier rate) / shipper rate
  • Markup = (shipper rate minus carrier rate) / carrier rate

The 13.5%, 18.3% and 22.8% above are margins on the shipper's rate. Markup is always the bigger percentage, so don't compare a markup figure to them.

Estimate the broker's cut in four steps

Example: say a 700-mile load is offered at $2.65 a mile, which is $1,855. Your all-in cost is $2.55 a mile, deadhead included.

Copy this and use your own numbers:

  1. Pick a low and a high margin. Use 13.5% and 22.8%.
  2. Divide your offer by (1 minus the margin). Low: $1,855 / 0.865 = about $2,145. High: $1,855 / 0.772 = about $2,403. That's the likely shipper rate, about $3.06 to $3.43 a mile.
  3. Subtract your offer. The broker keeps about $290 to $548. Over 700 miles, that's roughly $0.41 to $0.78 a mile.
  4. Compare it to your own gap. The offer leaves you $0.10 a mile over cost, about $70 for the load. Your $70 is the number you can check.

Margin and markup on the same load: if the shipper pays $2,240 ($3.20 a mile), the broker keeps $385. That's about 17% of the shipper's rate and about 21% of what you're paid.

A 13.5% versus 22.8% margin moves the broker's cut by $258 on one load

Here's the same $1,855 offer at the three sourced margins.

Broker marginLikely shipper rateBroker keepsPer mile (700 miles)
13.5%$2,145$290$0.41
18.3%$2,271$416$0.59
22.8%$2,403$548$0.78

The spread is $258, more than three times the $70 you clear at the offered rate. You can't pin down the broker's number. You don't need to. If the offer leaves you less per mile than you need, counter.

Ask for the rate and any room, not the broker's percentage

You can ask what the shipper is paying, but you may not get an answer. FreightWaves reported shipper confidentiality as an issue at the FMCSA broker transparency hearing, so a broker who stays quiet may be bound to.

Try this instead: "What's the rate on this load, and is there any room?" It asks about the offer, not the broker's cut, and it's harder to refuse. If you get nothing, name your number. Your break-even is the one figure you control, and the break-even rate per mile guide shows how to get it.

Use a lane average to check the offer, never to guess the shipper rate

Broker-to-carrier spot rates are what brokers pay carriers, so they already leave out the broker's margin. That makes a lane average from a rate tool a fair check on the carrier side of the offer.

Compare it like this: (lane average minus your offer) / lane average. If the offer sits well below the lane average, you have a reason to counter that has nothing to do with the broker's cut.

Don't add a guessed margin on top of a lane average and call it the shipper rate. That counts the broker's cut twice.

Counter with one number and one reason, then stop talking

Script: "My all-in on this lane is $2.55 with the deadhead. I can run it at $2.95."

On 700 miles, $2.95 is $2,065, which is $210 more than the offer and leaves you about $280 over cost. If the shipper pays the $2,240 from the example, the broker still keeps about $175, roughly 8%. You're not asking them to work for free. You're asking for a smaller cut on a load that has to cover your costs. For more wording, see how to negotiate freight rates with brokers.

If they say $2.65 is their best, check it against your break-even. If it fails, walk. A rate that fails your break-even fails whatever the broker keeps.

Two mistakes that cost you the load or the margin

MistakeWhat it costs
Arguing about the broker's percentageThe call turns into a fight over a number nobody on it can check, and you never reach your own number.
Quoting a rate without deadheadThe empty miles to pickup are unpaid, so a rate that looks fine on loaded miles can sit under break-even.

Take it, counter it or walk: pick by your break-even

IfDo this
The broker won't say the shipper rateGive your all-in number with one reason.
The offer is under the lane averageCounter, using the lane average as your reason.
The offer clears your break-even and the profit you needTake it. The broker's cut doesn't matter.
The offer fails your break-even and they won't moveWalk.
A margin figure looks too highCheck whether it's a margin on the shipper rate or a markup on the carrier rate.

Run the four steps on your last offered load in the next ten minutes

Pull up the last load you were offered. Write down the offer, the loaded miles and your all-in cost per mile. Run the four steps with 13.5% and 22.8%. Then write the one-line counter you would have made.

Keep your load math in one place

Once you know your all-in number, every offer is a quick comparison. HaulMath is built for owner-operators and small fleets who run this kind of load math. Try HaulMath

Common questions

How much does a freight broker keep on a load?
A broker keeps the gap between the shipper's rate and the carrier's rate. Tabi Connect's index shows a 13.5% dataset average, 18.3% on recent spot loads and 22.8% at the high end, all as a share of the shipper's rate. It varies by load, lane and market.
Can I ask a broker what the shipper is paying?
You can ask, but the broker may not tell you, since shippers often require confidentiality. A better question is "What's the rate on this load, and is there any room?" If you get no answer, name your all-in number and one reason.
Is broker margin the same as markup?
No. Margin is the broker's cut divided by the shipper's rate. Markup is the same dollars divided by the carrier's rate. Markup is always the bigger percentage.
How do I estimate the shipper rate from my offer?
Divide your offer by (1 minus the margin). A $1,855 offer at an 18.3% margin implies about $2,271. Run it with a low and a high margin to get a range.
Are spot rate averages what the shipper pays?
No. Broker-to-carrier spot rates are what brokers pay carriers, and they exclude the broker's margin. Use them to check the offer, not to guess the shipper rate.

Run your own numbers

Free calculators for owner-operators: load profit, cost per mile, IFTA, per diem, and more. Every answer shows the math.

Free, no signup

Know your number before you take the load

26 free calculators, no signup. Want your loads and numbers saved? Try Pro free for 14 days, no card.

Get the free cost-per-mile sheetStart the free Pro trial