Blog
How to Price a Load When You Pay a Hired Driver Per Mile
The cents per mile you pay a driver are not your driver cost. Add payroll taxes and workers comp, find your break-even per loaded mile, and know what to tell the broker.
Price the load on your truck cost per mile plus your loaded driver cost per mile, not the cents you pay the driver. By the end of this post you can work out your break-even per loaded mile with a hired driver on the truck and tell a broker exactly what number you need.
Payroll taxes and workers comp sit on top of the pay rate. If you leave them out, a load that looks fine on the rate confirmation can quietly lose money.
Your driver costs more than the cents on the settlement
One owner on The Truckers Report worked out that a driver paid 39 cents a mile comes to roughly 53 cents a mile once taxes and workers comp are added. That is one person's math, so use it as a warning, not as your number. Yours comes from your own payroll records.
FreightWaves counts more than wages when it talks about driver cost. Its breakdown of total operating cost per mile includes base wages, incentive pay, per diem, accessorial pay, workers comp, health insurance and retirement benefits. It reports driver compensation ranging from $0.48 to $0.83 per mile.
So the number that goes into your price is the loaded driver cost per mile:
Loaded driver cost per mile = pay per mile + employer payroll tax per mile + workers comp per mile + any other payroll cost per mile
Get your add-on per mile from last month's records in 4 steps
- Write down how the driver is paid: cents per mile, a percentage, or a mix.
- Pull one month of driver pay, employer payroll taxes and workers comp from your payroll records and your insurance bill.
- Divide those totals by every mile the driver ran that month, loaded plus empty.
- Compare the result with the pay rate you quote the driver. The gap is your add-on per mile.
Ask your payroll provider one plain question: "What is my year to date employer tax total for this driver?" Divide that by year to date miles. For workers comp, divide the policy premium by the same miles. Re-run all of it every quarter, because insurance and tax costs move.
Then put the result next to your truck cost per mile. If you have not built that number yet, how to calculate your trucking cost per mile walks through it line by line.
What the employer side of payroll actually adds
If the driver is a W-2 employee, you pay the employer share of payroll tax on top of wages:
- FICA: 7.65 percent of wages, which is 6.2 percent Social Security plus 1.45 percent Medicare, per Netchex. Social Security stops at the annual wage base.
- FUTA: a net 0.6 percent on the first $7,000 of each employee's wages, per ustax.tools.
- SUTA: state unemployment tax, which varies by state and by employer.
- Workers comp: comes from your policy, not from a tax table.
Rates and wage bases change, so confirm the current figures with your accountant or payroll provider before you lock in a price.
FUTA only hits the first $7,000 of wages, so it weighs more per mile early in the year and less later. Price on the yearly average, not on one month.
Worked example: a 600-mile trip at $2.80 a loaded mile
Example: say your driver runs 500 loaded miles and 100 empty miles to get back, 600 total. You pay 55 cents a mile on every mile driven. A broker offers $2.80 per loaded mile. These numbers are for illustration. Swap in yours.
| Line | Per mile | On 600 miles |
|---|---|---|
| Driver pay, 55 cents | $0.550 | $330.00 |
| Employer FICA, 7.65% of pay | $0.042 | $25.20 |
| FUTA, SUTA and workers comp (say 8 cents from your bills) | $0.080 | $48.00 |
| Loaded driver cost | $0.672 | $403.20 |
| Truck cost (fuel, maintenance, tires, insurance, payments, say $1.45) | $1.450 | $870.00 |
| Total cost | $2.122 | $1,273.20 |
The break-even rate is total cost per mile divided by the share of miles that are loaded: $2.122 / (500 / 600) = $2.55 per loaded mile. Our break-even rate per mile guide covers that step in full.
Now check the offer:
- Revenue: 500 loaded miles x $2.80 = $1,400.00
- Cost: $1,273.20
- What is left: $126.80, about 25 cents per loaded mile
The driver cost per loaded mile here is $403.20 / 500, about 81 cents, not the 55 cents on the settlement. That is 29 percent of the $2.80 rate. FreightWaves reports that driver compensation, benefits and payroll taxes together run 28 percent to 50 percent of revenue, depending on region, operating mode and length of haul. Use that range as a sanity check, not a target. If your share is far above it, the lane or the rate is probably the problem.
Tell the broker your number in one sentence
Once you know the break-even, say it plainly and add the margin you want:
"My all-in cost is $2.55 a loaded mile on this lane. I need at least $2.95 to run it."
The $2.95 is break-even plus 40 cents, an example margin. Pick your own. Do not explain the driver math to the broker. The number is enough, and it shows you know where you stand.
Percent pay: convert it to cents per loaded mile first
If you pay the driver a percentage of the load, you cannot compare it with truck cost until it is in cents per mile.
Cents per loaded mile = percent x rate per loaded mile
Example: 30 percent of a $2.80 rate is 84 cents per loaded mile. At $2.40 it is 72 cents. The percentage looks small, but it moves with the rate, while per mile pay does not. Add employer payroll tax and workers comp on top, exactly as above.
If the driver is paid only on loaded miles, check how the empty miles fit. The truck still burns fuel and wears tires on them, and the driver cost per total mile is lower than per loaded mile.
Treat a 1099 driver as a question for your accountant, not a discount
A true 1099 contractor has no employer payroll tax. That does not mean you can plan your price around it. Whether a driver really counts as a contractor is a classification question for an accountant or attorney. Price your loads with the W-2 add-on until you have that answer in writing.
Pick the right move for the load in front of you
| If this is true | Do this |
|---|---|
| Rate covers truck cost and loaded driver cost with room left | Take it, or push for more if the room is thin |
| Rate covers truck cost but not loaded driver cost | Counter, or pass. You would be paying to run the load |
| Driver is paid on loaded miles but the truck runs empty miles too | Price the empty miles in. Per paid mile understates your cost per total mile |
| Short load with long waits | Price the load on its own numbers, not on a month's average |
| Your driver cost looks low next to the $0.48 to $0.83 range | Check for missing payroll taxes, workers comp or benefits before you quote |
Waiting costs you even when the driver is not paid by the mile
Per mile pay is a variable cost. The truck's payments and insurance are fixed, and they keep running while the truck sits at a dock. Overdrive makes the same point: evaluate any load's cost in relation to time, not just miles. A 500-mile load with 6 hours of waiting is a different load from one that loads and rolls.
If the rate confirmation allows it, bill the wait. Before you sign anything, run through the rate confirmation checklist.
Four mistakes that make a bad load look good
- Pricing off the pay rate alone. Payroll taxes and workers comp are left out, so every load looks better than it is.
- Ignoring empty miles. Cost per loaded mile is always higher than cost per total mile.
- Using last year's numbers. Fuel and insurance move, and the same rate leaves a different margin.
- Applying 7.65 percent once and stopping. FUTA, SUTA and workers comp are still missing, so the add-on is more than the FICA match.
Your next ten minutes
Open last month's payroll report and your workers comp bill. Add driver pay, employer payroll taxes and workers comp. Divide by every mile that driver ran. Subtract the pay rate and you have your add-on per mile. Write it on a sticky note on the dash or in your phone, next to your truck cost per mile.
Do this math before the broker asks
Once the add-on per mile is in your numbers, every load comes down to one comparison: the rate against your break-even. If you want the arithmetic done for you while the broker waits, Try HaulMath and run your own figures through it.
Common questions
- Do I pay payroll taxes on top of per mile pay?
- If the driver is a W-2 employee, yes. You pay the employer share of FICA, FUTA and your state unemployment tax on top of wages, plus workers comp from your policy. Ask your accountant or payroll provider for the current rates.
- How do I turn a percentage of the load into cents per mile?
- Multiply the percentage by the rate per loaded mile. Thirty percent of a $2.80 rate is 84 cents per loaded mile. Then add employer payroll tax and workers comp, just as you would for per mile pay.
- Do I price in empty miles?
- Yes. The truck burns fuel and wears tires on empty miles, and fixed costs keep running. Divide your total cost per mile by the share of miles that are loaded to get the break-even per loaded mile.
- What share of the rate should go to the driver?
- FreightWaves reports that driver compensation, benefits and payroll taxes together run 28 to 50 percent of revenue, depending on region, operating mode and length of haul. Use that as a sanity check against your own records, not as a target.
- Is a hired driver cheaper as a 1099 contractor?
- A true 1099 contractor has no employer payroll tax, but whether a driver counts as one is a classification question. Ask an accountant or attorney before you build your pricing around it.
Run your own numbers
Free calculators for owner-operators: load profit, cost per mile, IFTA, per diem, and more. Every answer shows the math.