Blog
Practical Miles vs Shortest Miles: Which One Does the Broker Pay On?
The miles on your rate confirmation often come in lower than the miles you drive. Here is how to find the gap, price it in dollars, and counter with a total instead of arguing about maps.
Ask the broker which routing setting the miles came from, then run the same trip on practical miles and price the difference in dollars. If the gap costs you real money, counter with a flat total instead of arguing about whose map is right. By the end of this post you will have a four-step calculation and a counter line you can paste into a text.
The miles on the rate confirmation are often not the miles you drive
Most mileage programs let the user pick a routing setting. PC*Miler, the program behind most load boards and used in most IFTA audits, offers a practical setting and a shortest 53-foot setting. Practical keeps a truck on the interstate system and around major cities, so the number comes out higher. Shortest takes the shortest legal path for a big truck, so the number comes out lower. The Truckers Report forum thread on practical, hub and shortest miles lays out the two settings.
A third option shows up in some tools. Freightview's guide to mileage options describes practical as the default, which balances speed and route efficiency, and fastest, which picks the quickest route even if it adds miles to stay on highways.
The same forum thread says truckers are typically paid on the shortest miles that can be done in a big truck, not on practical miles. That matches what a lot of drivers report. It does not tell you what your broker does on your load. Only the broker can tell you that, so you ask.
One lane shows how big the gap can get
The forum thread gives a real pair of numbers. Saint Louis, MO to Amherst, NH is 1,163.3 miles on the shortest setting and 1,198.2 miles on practical. That is a gap of 34.9 miles, or 3.0 percent.
At 40 cents a mile, the thread works that out to $13.96 on the run. At a headline rate closer to what owner-operators chase, the same gap costs more.
Example: say the broker pays $2.00 a paid mile on the shortest number.
| Miles | What it means | |
|---|---|---|
| Paid miles (shortest) | 1,163.3 | The load pays 1,163.3 x $2.00 = $2,326.60 |
| Miles you drive (practical) | 1,198.2 | You run 34.9 miles the broker never counted |
| Effective rate | $2,326.60 divided by 1,198.2 = about $1.94 a mile | |
| Total needed for a true $2.00 | 1,198.2 x $2.00 = $2,396.40, which is $69.80 more |
The $2.00 on the load board turned into $1.94 on the road. That is the number you compare to your cost per mile. If your break-even sits at $1.95, a load that looked fine on paper just went under.
Price the mileage gap in dollars in four steps
This is the calculation to repeat with your own figures on every load that smells off.
- Get both numbers. Write down the miles on the rate confirmation. Then run the same pickup and delivery addresses in a truck mileage tool on the practical setting. Trimble describes PC*MILER|Web as giving owner-operators truck-specific mileage for rate calculation and fuel tax reporting, so it is a good place to check. A car route from a map app can miss truck restrictions.
- Find the gap in miles and percent. Practical miles minus paid miles is the gap. Divide the gap by paid miles and multiply by 100 for the percent.
- Price the gap. Gap in miles times the rate per paid mile is what the mileage setting costs you on this load.
- Find your effective rate. Total pay divided by the miles you will actually drive. Compare that to your break-even, not the rate on the board.
If you need the break-even number, the break-even rate per mile guide walks through it.
Small gap on a short load? Check the dollars before you argue
The percent can look scary while the dollars are tiny, and the other way around.
Example: say a 250-mile load pays a flat $500, and your practical route is 258 miles.
The gap is 8 miles, about 3.2 percent. At $2.00 a mile that is $16. Your effective rate is $500 divided by 258, or about $1.94. If the load clears your break-even with room to spare, take it and move on. If it only just clears, the $16 is the difference between a good load and a wash.
This is where a lot of drivers waste a phone call. They argue for ten minutes about miles on a load where the whole gap is a tank-fill of coffee. Do the math first. Then decide whether it is worth it.
Counter with a total, not with a map
When the gap is worth chasing, do not argue about whose miles are right. Mileage programs differ, settings differ, and the broker will have a screen that says what it says. You will not win that argument and you will burn the goodwill you need for the rate talk.
Counter with a flat total instead. You work out what the trip has to pay at your target rate on the miles you really run, and you ask for that number.
Flat-total counter = your driven miles x your target rate per driven mile, plus any tolls or extra stops you have to cover.
Using the Saint Louis example: 1,198.2 driven miles x $2.00 = $2,396.40. Round to $2,400 and ask for that.
Here is the line to paste into a text or say on the phone:
The rate confirmation shows [paid miles]. My route is [driven miles]. To run it I need [total], all in. Can you send an updated rate confirmation at that number?
Keep it to the total, one reason, and a request for paperwork. Freight negotiation guides say the same thing in general terms: name your rate, name your reason, and ask for the rate confirmation. For more on what to say when the broker pushes back, see what to do when the broker says that's the best I can do.
If you only remember three rules, make it these
| If the paperwork says... | Do this |
|---|---|
| Shortest, or household goods miles | Assume the paid miles are lower than the road you will run. Price the load on your own practical route. |
| Practical | Ask which mileage program it came from. Results can differ between programs. |
| Nothing about the setting | Ask once: "Which routing setting did you use for these miles?" Write down the answer. |
Household goods (HHG) mileage calculates the shortest route between two points, which is not always the best route for a truck. The forum thread notes there is no standard percentage gap for it, so check each route on its own. Do not carry a rule of thumb from one lane to the next.
Three mistakes that cost you miles
- Treating shortest and practical as the same number. In the sample lane that is 34.9 miles you run for free.
- Comparing the board rate to your cost per mile without checking the mileage basis. In the example, about 6 cents of every $2.00 mile disappears. Over a long haul that adds up fast.
- Assuming every broker uses the same setting. One load can look good, and the next one on the same lane can pay less because a different broker, or a different program, set the miles.
Your next ten minutes
Pull up the last rate confirmation you signed and check it.
- Write down the paid miles from the confirmation.
- Run the same addresses on the practical setting in a truck mileage tool.
- Subtract, then multiply the gap by the rate per mile.
- Divide total pay by the miles you actually drove.
- Compare that effective rate to your break-even.
If the effective rate came in under your break-even, you now know what to ask the broker next time. If it held up, you know that broker's miles are close to yours, and that is worth knowing too.
When you want that math to run in seconds instead of on a notepad, try HaulMath. It does the freight math so you can see what a load really pays before you say yes.
Common questions
- Does the broker pay practical miles or shortest miles?
- It depends on the broker and the mileage program they use. Drivers on trucker forums report that shortest miles are common, but you should ask on every load which routing setting produced the number.
- What is the difference between practical, shortest and fastest miles?
- Practical keeps a truck on the interstate system and around major cities. Shortest takes the shortest legal path for a big truck. Fastest chooses the quickest route even if it adds miles to stay on highways.
- What are HHG miles?
- Household goods miles calculate the shortest route between two points, which is not always the best route for a truck. The gap from practical miles varies by route, so there is no standard percentage.
- How do I ask for more money when the paid miles are low?
- Counter with a flat total instead of arguing about the map. Multiply the miles you will actually drive by your target rate, add tolls or extra stops, and ask the broker to send an updated rate confirmation at that number.
- Is a small mileage gap worth arguing about on a short load?
- Check the dollars first. Multiply the gap in miles by the rate per mile. If the load still clears your break-even by a comfortable margin, it may not be worth a phone call.
Run your own numbers
Free calculators for owner-operators: load profit, cost per mile, IFTA, per diem, and more. Every answer shows the math.