Blog
How to Know If a Broker Is Lowballing You
A broker is lowballing you when the offer sits under what the lane has recently paid and close to what the load costs you to run. Here are three checks to run before you answer, a verdict table and the words to use on the call.
A broker is lowballing you when the offer sits under what that lane has recently paid and close to, or under, what the load costs you to run. Run three checks before you call back: the lane average, your own floor, and the broker's likely margin. By the end you will have a number to counter with.
An offer under the lane average is a lowball, and the gap is the number to argue
Pull the exact lane (origin, destination, equipment) on DAT or Truckstop. Look at the average for the past 15 days and write down the high end. Bubba's guide to negotiating with freight brokers walks through the same check: when the broker says $2.10 a mile and the lane averages $2.35 with highs at $2.55, you have something concrete to push back with.
Make sure you are comparing like with like. DAT says its rates come from real payments reported by brokers, carriers and shippers, and should be used as a benchmark and starting point. The same guide says to match the timeframe, the geography and what the rate includes, for example linehaul only against all-in.
Example: say the offer is $2.10 a mile on 500 loaded miles, and the lane has averaged $2.35 with highs at $2.55 over 15 days.
| Per mile | On 500 miles | |
|---|---|---|
| Offer | $2.10 | $1,050 |
| Lane average | $2.35 | $1,175 |
| Lane high | $2.55 | $1,275 |
| Gap to average | $0.25 | $125 |
| Gap to high | $0.45 | $225 |
The formula to repeat: gap in dollars = (lane average per mile minus offer per mile) x loaded miles.
A $125 gap on one load is the number you take to the call.
Your floor decides counter or walk, and it has to include the empty miles
The lane average tells you what the market pays. It does not tell you whether you can run the load at that price. For that you need your floor: the lowest rate per loaded mile at which the load does not lose you money.
Example: say your all-in cost is $1.85 a mile, and the pickup is 40 empty miles from where you will be.
- Total miles: 500 loaded plus 40 empty = 540.
- Cost to run the load: 540 x $1.85 = $999.
- Floor per loaded mile: $999 / 500 = $2.00.
So the floor is about $2.00 a loaded mile, not $1.85. The $2.10 offer clears it by $0.10 a mile, or $51 for the whole load. The lane average of $2.35 would leave $1,175 minus $999, which is $176.
The formula: floor per loaded mile = (loaded miles + empty miles) x your cost per mile / loaded miles. If you have not worked out your own cost per mile, start with the break-even rate per mile guide, and see how deadhead miles change the number.
If you do not know your cost yet, use the industry average as a rough reference only. The American Transportation Research Institute reports an average operating cost of $2.260 a mile in 2024, including a record $1.779 a mile before fuel. The same report puts truckload carriers at an average margin of about negative 2.3 percent for the year. A $2.10 offer sits $0.16 a mile under that average, which is $80 on 500 miles. Your own number matters more than the average, because your truck payment, insurance and lanes are yours.
Broker margin shows how much room there is, but it is the weakest check
A broker keeps the difference between what the customer pays and what they pay you. One guide puts typical full truckload margin at $200 to $500 a load, or 12 to 20 percent, with operating costs of $120 to $160 a load coming out of that. Trade coverage of the Tabi Connect index reported broker-awarded margin hitting 22 percent, up from 17.8 percent the month before and 4 points over the 18 percent historical average.
The formula: broker margin percent = (customer rate minus your rate) / customer rate x 100.
Example: say the customer pays $1,400 for the 500 mile load. At an 18 percent margin the broker keeps $252 and you get $1,148, which is about $2.30 a mile. At your $1,050 offer the broker keeps $350, which is 25 percent.
You rarely get to see the customer rate, so do not build your call around it. Use margin as a sanity check when you can estimate it, and argue with the lane data, which you can show. Telling a broker their margin is too high gives them nothing to respond to. Telling them the lane has averaged $2.35 for 15 days does.
Three checks and a verdict table
| Offer vs lane average | Offer vs your floor | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| At or above | Above | Fair. Take it after you check the other terms. |
| Below | Above | Lowball. Counter at the average, and ask for more if the lane is tight. |
| Below | Below | Walk. |
| At or above | Below | Walk. The market rate is one you cannot run at. |
| No lane data yet | Unknown | Say you will call back. Do not name a number first. |
In the example, the offer is under the average and just above the floor. That is a lowball you can counter, and the counter has room: at $2.35 you move from a $51 profit to $176.
Say this on the call
- "What's the all-in rate on this one, and does it include fuel?" (So you compare the same thing.)
- "I'm seeing this lane average $2.35 over the last 15 days. I can run it at $2.35."
- If they hold: "I can't make $2.10 work with the empty miles to pickup. Let me know if that changes."
No apology and no story. If you agree, get the number on the rate confirmation before you move. For more on the back and forth after the first counter, see how to negotiate freight rates with brokers.
Four mistakes that make a fair offer look like a lowball, or the reverse
- Comparing linehaul to all-in. A rate with fuel surcharge folded in will look higher than a linehaul-only number. Ask which one it is.
- Using the posted rate as the lane average. A posted rate is one offer. The 15-day average is what the lane has paid.
- Leaving out the empty miles. The example above: $1.85 became a $2.00 floor once 40 empty miles were counted.
- Naming your number first without data. If you cannot pull the lane in time, say you will call back. You will anchor low otherwise.
Do this in the next ten minutes
- Write down your all-in cost per mile.
- Pick the last offer you took or turned down and pull that lane's 15-day average and high.
- Work out the floor with the empty miles and the gap to the average, using the table above.
If the last offer was under both, you have the line for the next call.
Check your own numbers
You now have the three checks and the words to use. If you want to see where your own cost per mile and your last offer land, Try HaulMath.
Common questions
- How do I know what a fair rate per mile is for my lane?
- Look up the exact lane on DAT or Truckstop and read the average for the past 15 days and the high end. Match the timeframe, the geography and whether the rate includes fuel before you compare it to the broker's offer.
- How much does a freight broker usually keep?
- One guide puts typical full truckload margin at $200 to $500 a load, or 12 to 20 percent, with trade reports of margins above that when the market favors brokers. Treat it as a range, not a rule, and argue with lane data instead.
- Should I counter or walk away from a low offer?
- Counter when the offer is under the lane average but above your floor. Walk when it is below your floor, because a rate you cannot run at is a losing load whatever the lane shows.
- What is my floor and how do I include empty miles?
- Your floor is the lowest rate per loaded mile that covers your cost. Add the empty miles to the loaded miles, multiply by your cost per mile, and divide by the loaded miles.
- Is the industry average cost per mile a good floor for me?
- Only as a reference. ATRI reports an average of $2.260 a mile for 2024, but your truck payment, insurance and lanes decide your real number, so calculate your own.
Run your own numbers
Free calculators for owner-operators: load profit, cost per mile, IFTA, per diem, and more. Every answer shows the math.