Skip to content
Haul Math

Blog

How to Calculate What to Charge for a Backhaul

Scott Wilder
By , Editor
Updated

Price a return load with two numbers: a floor that covers the variable cost of every mile, empty miles included, and a target that makes the round trip reach break-even. Here is how to work both out.

Never take a backhaul for less than the variable cost of every mile it makes you drive, empty miles to the pickup included. Then check that your headhaul and backhaul average out to your break-even. By the end of this post you can price any return load with two numbers: a floor you never go under and a target you ask for.

Your floor is variable cost, not break-even

Break-even covers everything: truck payment, insurance, permits, fuel, repairs, tires, and what you pay yourself. Most of that bill arrives whether the wheels turn or not. A return load only has to beat the part that depends on the wheels turning.

So split your cost per mile in two. Variable cost is fuel, repair and maintenance, and tires, plus tolls on lanes that have them. Fuel per mile is your fuel price per gallon divided by your real mpg.

For a sanity check, ATRI's benchmark puts the average cost of running a truck at $2.336 a mile, and $1.85 without fuel, with fuel at about $0.482 a mile. Repair and maintenance came in at 40.4 cents a mile and tires at 5 cents. Add those three and you get about $0.94 a mile. That sum is plain arithmetic on their averages, and your truck will differ, but it tells you roughly where a real number lands.

If your own variable cost comes out at $0.50, you left something out. Repairs and tires add about 45 cents a mile on those averages, so a fuel-only floor undercounts by almost half.

Count the empty miles to the pickup before you quote

The rate on the screen is per loaded mile. You also drive the empty miles to get there, and nobody pays you for those. Spread them over the loaded miles:

Floor per loaded mile = variable cost per mile x (empty miles to pickup + loaded miles) / loaded miles

Example: say your variable cost is $0.95 a mile. The reload is 45 miles from where you unload and runs 300 loaded miles.

StepMathResult
Total miles you drive45 + 300345
Variable cost of those miles345 x $0.95$327.75
Floor per loaded mile$327.75 / 300$1.09

A $1.00 offer on that load loses money on the miles alone. A $1.30 offer ($390) pays you about $62 over the cost of running it. Same lane, same truck, and the empty miles decided it.

Keep the deadhead to the pickup short. One trucker-focused guide suggests a ceiling of about 40 to 50 miles to reach a reload unless the market you land in is clearly better, because you are already accepting a low rate. The guide on what empty miles cost covers how to price them in.

A low backhaul beats running empty when it clears the floor

The question is not "does this match my headhaul rate?" It is "am I better off with this load or with an empty trailer?" DAT's backhaul versus headhaul guide explains why the two are priced differently: a headhaul market forms when shipper demand for a lane is higher than the trucks available, and a backhaul market forms when there are more trucks than freight. A dry van load from Los Angeles to Denver typically pays more than the same load coming back. The return lane is priced by a weaker market, not by your costs.

Example: say you unload 400 miles from home and the next headhaul out of home pays the same either way. Variable cost is $0.95 a mile.

Run emptyTake a $700 backhaul home
Pay$0$700
Variable cost (400 miles)$380$380
What the trip leavesLoses $380Leaves $320

That is $1.75 a mile. If your full break-even is $2.10 a mile ($840 over 400 miles), the load is $140 short of it. It is still $700 better than the empty trip, and your fixed costs run whether you drive or not. DAT's guide makes the same call: a low backhaul usually beats deadheading as long as revenue exceeds what it costs to run.

Make the round trip hit break-even, not each leg

Taking a cheap backhaul is only smart if the headhaul makes up for it. BigRoad's breakdown says the same: when you take very low per-mile backhauls, the average of the two rates has to meet break-even, which covers the bills and leaves no profit.

Round trip average = (headhaul pay + backhaul pay) / (all loaded miles + all empty miles)

Example: say a 400-mile headhaul pays $2.60 a mile ($1,040) and the 400-mile return pays $1.00 ($400). That is $1,440 over 800 miles, an average of $1.80. Against a $2.10 break-even, you are short.

Work backward to see what would fix it:

  • Headhaul needed = (break-even x round trip miles minus backhaul pay) / headhaul miles. Here: ($2.10 x 800 minus $400) / 400 = $3.20 a mile.
  • Backhaul needed if the headhaul stays at $2.60: ($2.10 x 800 minus $1,040) / 400 = $1.60 a mile.

Now you know what to ask. If the broker will not move the return load past $1.00, the headhaul has to carry the trip, and you should have priced it that way before you left. The break-even guide shows how to get the $2.10 in the first place.

What to do with an offer: a decision table

The offer, per loaded mileWhat to do
Below your floorPass, or counter above the floor. Empty costs less.
Above the floor, below break-evenTake it only if the alternative is running empty. Check the round trip average and price the headhaul to cover the gap.
At or above break-evenTake it, then ask whether you can push the rate higher.

Add one more check. If the reload lands you in a weaker market than where you are, the next headhaul may pay less. SONAR's piece on why destination matters is a good read on that. A slightly lower rate into a stronger market can beat a higher rate into a dead one.

Say it in one number and one condition

Keep the counter short. Paste this and fill in the brackets:

"I'm at [city] after unloading. What can you do on [pickup] to [drop], [miles] miles? My number is [rate] all in, and I need detention and fuel surcharge on the rate confirmation."

One number, one condition. Do not explain your costs to the broker. If you want more ideas on how to hold your number, the guide to negotiating rates with brokers goes deeper.

Mistakes that quietly eat the return trip

  • Pricing the backhaul against your headhaul rate. The two lanes have different supply and demand. A "bad" rate can be the right call.
  • Forgetting the empty miles to the pickup. Your real rate per mile drops because you only count the loaded miles.
  • Using an old cost number. ATRI found tolls up 13.2 percent, repair and maintenance up 8.6 percent, and tires up 6.4 percent in its latest report. A floor you set a year ago may now be low.
  • Treating a "buck a mile" load as free money. It still burns fuel, adds wear, and uses hours on your clock.

Do this in the next ten minutes

  1. Pull last month's fuel, repair, and tire spend.
  2. Divide each by the miles you drove.
  3. Add the three. That is your variable cost per mile.
  4. Multiply by the total miles of the next reload you are looking at, empty miles included, and write that number down as your floor.

Get your floor before the next call

If you would rather not run this on a napkin with a broker waiting, HaulMath is built for owner-operators who need freight and cost math fast. Try HaulMath and put your own cost per mile into the numbers above.

Common questions

How much should I charge for a backhaul?
At least the variable cost of every mile it makes you drive, including empty miles to the pickup. Then aim for a rate that makes the headhaul and backhaul average out to your break-even per mile.
Is a low paying backhaul better than deadheading?
Usually yes, as long as the pay is above the variable cost of the miles it adds. A load that pays less than break-even but more than variable cost still contributes toward your fixed costs.
What counts as a variable cost on a backhaul?
Fuel, repair and maintenance, and tires, plus tolls on the lane. Truck payments, insurance and permits come due whether the wheels turn or not, so they belong in break-even, not the floor.
Do I count the empty miles to the pickup?
Yes. You pay for those miles in fuel and wear but only get paid for the loaded miles, so spread their cost over the loaded miles when you set your floor.
How do I find the average rate for a round trip?
Add the headhaul pay and the backhaul pay, then divide by all the miles you drove, loaded and empty. Compare that number to your break-even rate per mile.
How far should I deadhead to reach a reload?
One trucker-focused guide suggests keeping it to about 40 to 50 miles unless the market you land in is clearly better. Run the floor formula with your own numbers before you decide.

Run your own numbers

Free calculators for owner-operators: load profit, cost per mile, IFTA, per diem, and more. Every answer shows the math.