Blog
How to Counter a Broker Rate When the Load Board Shows Higher
The board says one number and the broker says another. Convert both to the same unit, check them against your floor, then counter once with a script you can read off the page.
Convert the broker's number and the board number to the same unit, compare the broker's number to your own floor, then counter once and be ready to walk. By the end of this post you will have a five-step check and a script you can use on the next call.
The board is the broker's opening position. OTrucking's load board guide says to always counter and never take the first offered rate. A counter only works if you know two numbers: what the lane is posted at, and the lowest rate that still pays you. Most drivers only know the first one.
Check the unit first: per mile and flat rate look like a gap that isn't
Half the "low-ball" calls are two people quoting different units. DAT says a poster can show a per mile rate or a flat per trip rate, and lanes under 250 miles always display a per trip rate. So the board might read $2.90 a mile while the broker says "fourteen ten, all in."
Convert before you react:
- Flat to per mile: flat rate divided by loaded miles.
- Per mile to flat: rate per loaded mile times loaded miles.
Compare only after both are in the same unit. If they match, there is no gap, and you have saved yourself an argument. If they do not, you now have a real number to bring up.
Check the posting before you quote it
A board rate is only a fair comparison when it describes the same load. Before you say "the board shows $2.90," check four things on the posting:
- Same equipment type as yours.
- Same pickup date and time window.
- Same loaded miles, not a shorter practical route.
- Whether it is a current posting or an old one.
If any of these differ, the board is not your comparison. Say what you are comparing: "I am seeing a similar dry van lane at $2.90." For how the posting differs from what a lane really pays, see Posted Rate vs Lane Average.
Run these five steps before you say a number
This is the part to save. It takes about two minutes once you have your cost per mile.
- Find your floor per loaded mile. Your all-in cost per mile times total miles, including the deadhead to the pickup, divided by loaded miles. Add the profit per mile you want. If you do not have a cost per mile, work it out first with How to Know Your Minimum Rate Per Mile.
- Convert the board rate and the broker's offer to the same unit.
- Compare the broker's number to your floor, not to the board. The board tells you what to ask for. Your floor tells you where to stop.
- Counter once. Say your number and one reason.
- If they will not move, ask about the terms and get the answer in writing on the rate confirmation.
Worked example: board at $2.90, broker at $1,410
Example: say the board shows $2.90 a mile on a 600 loaded mile lane. The broker offers $1,410 flat. Your all-in cost is $1.85 a mile, you run 80 miles empty to get to the pickup, and you want $0.40 a mile of profit.
| Step | Math | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Broker's offer per loaded mile | $1,410 divided by 600 | $2.35 |
| Board per loaded mile | given | $2.90 |
| Gap | ($2.90 minus $2.35) times 600 | $330 |
| Total miles | 600 plus 80 | 680 |
| Cost to run it | 680 times $1.85 | $1,258 |
| Break-even per loaded mile | $1,258 divided by 600 | about $2.10 |
| Your floor with $0.40 profit | $2.10 plus $0.40 | $2.50 |
The broker's $2.35 is under your $2.50 floor, so it is a no as offered. The board's $2.90 tells you there is room. A sensible counter sits between the two and above the floor, such as $2.75. The $330 gap is your talking point. You do not know what the broker's customer is paying, so use the gap to explain why you are asking, never to demand it.
Say it this way: one number, one reason, then stop talking
A short counter beats a long argument. Bubba's negotiation guide suggests staying calm and giving a counter with a reason, for example: "I appreciate the load, but I need $2.70 to make that lane work for me."
Here are scripts for the three moments you will hit.
The opening counter: "I am seeing this lane at $2.90 on the board. Can you get me to $2.75?"
When they say it is final: "I understand. What is the all-in number with detention and fuel?"
When the number is under your floor: "That does not cover my cost on this lane. If that changes, call me." Then end the call.
Give a number, not a range. A range hands them the bottom of it. For more on the "that's the best I can do" moment, read What to Do When the Broker Says "That's the Best I Can Do".
When the base rate is stuck, move to detention, layover and lumper terms
Sometimes a broker will not move on the rate but will move on the terms. That is a real counter, as long as it is on the paper you sign.
Detention is the time a truck waits past the agreed free window. OTrucking says it is an accessorial charge, not a legal entitlement, so the free time and the hourly rate have to be written into the rate confirmation. A two hour free window is described as the most common norm, but it is set per load and varies by broker and lane. The same site describes detention pay typically running about $50 to $100 an hour after free time, depending on the terms on the confirmation.
The math you can repeat: detention you can bill equals hours waited minus free hours, times the hourly rate.
Example: say your confirmation shows 2 hours free and $75 an hour after that. You wait 4.5 hours at the receiver. That is 2.5 billable hours, or $187.50. If it is not on the confirmation, that $187.50 is something you are asking for, not something you are owed.
What to ask for when the base rate is stuck:
- The free time and the hourly detention rate
- Layover pay if you are held overnight
- Who pays lumper fees, and whether you are reimbursed with a receipt
- A revised rate confirmation with the new terms before you move the truck
Keep your floor on the base rate and deadhead. Count detention only after it is in writing. Check the lines in What to Check on a Rate Confirmation Before You Sign before you accept.
Four mistakes that cost you the load or the margin
- Using the board as your floor. The board is the broker's posting. Your floor comes from your cost and your deadhead.
- Comparing a flat rate to a per mile rate. You can think you are being low-balled when you are not, or take a number that is lower than it sounds.
- Countering without a number you can walk away at. Without a floor, a counter is a guess.
- Agreeing on the phone and not getting it in writing. The rate confirmation is what you get paid from.
Your pre-call checklist
- Board rate noted, with per mile or flat marked
- Posting checked for equipment, date and miles
- Both rates converted to the same unit
- Floor per loaded mile written down, deadhead included
- Counter number and walk-away number decided
- Detention, layover and lumper questions ready
- Revised rate confirmation requested before you move
Do this in the next ten minutes
Pick the last load you took or turned down. Write down the board rate, the broker's offer and whether each was per mile or flat. Convert both to per loaded mile and put your floor next to them. If you do not have a floor, that is the first number to build.
Get your floor in seconds, then make the call
The hard part of this call is not the script. It is knowing your floor with deadhead in it while a broker is waiting on the line. Run your cost per mile and your break-even once, keep the numbers where you can see them, and the counter gets simple. Try HaulMath to run the freight math before you pick up the phone. A counter does not always work, and it is still better to decline a load under your floor than to take one that costs you money.
Common questions
- Why does the load board show more than the broker offered?
- Sometimes it is a real gap, and sometimes it is per mile versus flat rate. Convert both to rate per loaded mile first, then check that the posting matches your equipment, date and miles.
- Is the load board rate per mile or flat?
- It can be either. DAT says a poster can show a per mile or a flat per trip rate, and lanes under 250 miles always display a per trip rate.
- What do I say when a broker says the rate is final?
- Ask for the all-in number: "What is the all-in number with detention and fuel?" Then compare that total to your floor. If it is under your floor, say it does not cover your cost and end the call.
- Should I count detention in my floor?
- No. Build your floor on the base rate and deadhead, and count detention only once the free time and hourly rate are written on the rate confirmation.
- How do I know my floor?
- Take your all-in cost per mile times total miles including deadhead, divide by loaded miles, then add the profit per mile you want. Do it before you call.
Run your own numbers
Free calculators for owner-operators: load profit, cost per mile, IFTA, per diem, and more. Every answer shows the math.