Skip to content
Haul Math

Blog

Why You're Busy but Not Making Money Trucking

Scott Wilder
By , Editor
Updated

A few loads that looked fine on the rate sheet can wipe out a month once empty miles and waiting time are counted. Here is a one-sitting review that shows which ones.

You're busy but not making money because a few loads that looked fine on the rate sheet lose money once empty miles are counted. Re-price last month's loads at all-in miles, set each one against your cost per mile, and you'll see which lanes to stop running. The table below takes one sitting.

Re-price every load from last month at all-in miles

A rate per loaded mile hides the miles you drove empty to get there. Rate per all-in mile puts them back:

  • Rate per all-in mile = total pay / (loaded miles + deadhead miles to pick up)
  • Load profit = total pay minus (all-in miles x your all-in cost per mile)

Example: say your all-in cost is $2.45 a mile (build yours with the cost per mile guide) and you ran these five loads. The numbers are invented to show the method.

LoadPayLoaded miDeadhead miPer loaded milePer all-in mileProfit
A$1,80050060$3.60$3.21+$428
B$950280120$3.39$2.38-$30
C$2,20090040$2.44$2.34-$103
D$70022090$3.18$2.26-$59.50
E$1,500450200$3.33$2.31-$92.50

Total pay is $7,150 over 2,860 all-in miles. Cost at $2.45 is $7,007. That leaves $143 for the month. If those five loads tied up the truck 11 days, it's about $13 a day.

Four of the five paid over $3 a mile loaded. Only A made real money.

A $3 load can lose money, so judge it by the all-in column

Look at B and C. B pays $3.39 per loaded mile and loses $30. C pays only $2.44 per loaded mile and loses $103, but it nearly breaks even per all-in mile because it had just 40 empty miles. B's 120 empty miles ate it.

The gap between the two rate columns tells you how much deadhead is costing you. A big gap on a short load is the warning sign. For the empty-mile math on its own, see deadhead miles.

Rule: when a load pays over $3 per loaded mile but under your cost per all-in mile, it's a loser that looks like a winner. Don't take that lane at that rate again.

Run the month review in six steps

  1. Make a table with these columns: load, pay, loaded miles, deadhead miles, days tied up, rate per all-in mile, profit.
  2. Fill in every load from last month, including the ones you thought were good. Pull pay and miles from your rate confirmations and settlement statements.
  3. Add one more column: above or below your cost per mile.
  4. Sort by profit. Circle the best load and every load below zero.
  5. Write the lane of each loser on one line.
  6. Repeat on the first of every month.

If one lane shows up as a loser twice in a month, quote a floor that covers the empty miles, or pass. If you're on a lease, check each deduction against the settlement statement guide before you trust the pay column.

Count weak loads by days, not dollars

One strong load can hide four weak ones. A flat bank balance after a full month of driving is what that costs you.

Count the weak loads by the days they used. Every day on a load that pays under your cost is a day the truck couldn't take a better one. A load that sits at a dock turns a short run into a two or three day load, so profit per day drops even when profit per load looks positive. If you're owed detention, bill it, because unbilled waiting time is a fixed-cost day with no pay.

Check whether the rate has fuel in it before it goes in the table

Two quotes of "$2.60 a mile" aren't the same load if one has the fuel surcharge in it and one adds it on top. "$2.60 all-in" and "$1.90 plus $0.70 fuel" are the same number. Convert every rate to one form before you compare it to your cost.

DAT's published linehaul rates are the spot rate minus an average fuel surcharge, so a linehaul figure isn't comparable to an all-in quote. DAT also reported the average fuel surcharge rising from 62 cents to 70 cents a mile between June and August 2026. Fuel moves, so a rate that was fine in June can fall short in August if you don't re-run your cost.

Ask the broker two things and write both answers on your card:

"Is that rate with fuel in it, or plus fuel? What's the surcharge per mile, and is it paid on loaded miles only?"

The surcharge doesn't pay for your empty miles

A surcharge is paid on loaded miles. The truck burns fuel on empty miles too.

Example: say your five loads carried a 70 cent surcharge, you get 6.5 mpg, and diesel is $4.00.

  • Surcharge paid: 2,350 loaded miles x $0.70 = $1,645
  • Fuel burned: 2,860 all-in miles / 6.5 mpg = 440 gallons x $4.00 = $1,760

The surcharge falls $115 short of the fuel bill, and the difference comes out of your linehaul. Use your own mpg and your receipts. To work out how a surcharge is set, read the fuel surcharge guide.

Your cost number drifts, so check it against a real benchmark

An old cost per mile makes new loads look better than they are. ATRI's 2025 report put the industry average at a record $2.336 per mile, with the non-fuel part at $1.85. The lines that rose fastest were tolls (13.2 percent), repair and maintenance (8.6 percent), driver benefits (6.6 percent) and tires (6.4 percent).

That average also includes paid driver wages and benefits that you don't pay yourself as a separate line. So it's not your break-even. Use it to check that your own number isn't absurdly low. If it leaves out repairs, tires or tolls, it runs low.

Money set aside isn't profit

Drivers on forums say large incoming and outgoing checks make income look better than it is, and that quarterly taxes and the maintenance account are money already spoken for. Subtract your set-aside before you call a week good. The quarterly taxes guide covers when payments are due. For tax advice on your own situation, talk to a licensed accountant.

Drivers also describe contracts at a single carrier where the driver covers about 90 percent of expenses. Those leave thin margins, which is a good reason to run the table before you sign.

Put your rules on one card

If you see thisDo this
Rate per all-in mile is below your cost per mileCounter, or pass
Two loads pay about the same grossTake the one with fewer empty miles and less waiting
The same lane lost money twice this monthQuote a floor that covers the empty miles, or skip it
Deadhead is over X milesAdd Y per mile or pass. Pick X and Y from your own table
The broker quotes a rateAsk: fuel in it or plus fuel? Write the answer next to the number

On the call, say: "My number on that lane is X all-in. What can you do on the rate?"

Your next ten minutes

Take last month's rate confirmations and pick five loads. For each one, write the pay, the loaded miles, the deadhead miles and whether fuel was in the rate. Divide pay by all-in miles. Mark every load that came in under your cost per mile. That's your first month review, and it shows which lane to quote differently on Monday.

Run the next load before you say yes

Doing this by hand once a month shows you the problem. Doing it on every load before you commit is what fixes it. Try HaulMath to run the freight math on a load before you say yes.

Common questions

Why am I running all the time and still have no money?
Usually a few loads lose money once empty miles and waiting days are counted, and they cancel out the good ones. Re-price last month's loads at rate per all-in mile and compare each to your cost per mile to find them.
Is $3 a mile still good if I deadhead 100 miles?
Not automatically. Divide the total pay by loaded plus empty miles and compare that number to your all-in cost per mile. A $3 loaded rate with 100 empty miles on a short load can drop well under $2.50 all-in.
Do I count empty miles in my cost per mile?
Yes. Divide your total costs for the period by all miles driven, loaded and empty, because you pay for fuel and wear on both.
Is the fuel surcharge extra money or part of the rate?
Treat it as part of the pay that goes to the fuel bill. It is paid on loaded miles, so fuel burned on empty miles still comes out of your linehaul.
What should I ask a broker about the rate before I say yes?
Ask whether the rate has fuel in it or is plus fuel, what the surcharge is per mile, and whether it is paid on loaded miles only. Write the answers next to the number.
How often should I review my loads?
Once a month, on the first, with your rate confirmations and settlement statements in front of you. Re-run your cost per mile at the same time, since fuel and repair costs move.

Run your own numbers

Free calculators for owner-operators: load profit, cost per mile, IFTA, per diem, and more. Every answer shows the math.