Blog
What to Do When the Broker Says "That's the Best I Can Do"
When a broker says that's the best they can do, compare the offer to your floor rate before you answer. Here is the math, the decision table and the exact words for the final no.
When a broker says "that's the best I can do," don't answer yet. Check the offer against your floor rate. At or above it, take the load or make one small ask. Below it, decline politely and ask for the next load on that lane.
By the end of this post you'll have a floor-rate formula, a table that tells you whether to accept, and four lines you can say on the phone when the answer is no.
Know your floor before you pick up the call
A final offer is only a problem if you don't know your own number. Bestpass says carriers who know their true cost per mile can reject underpriced loads without second-guessing. Without that number, you either take loads that barely cover costs or turn down loads that pay.
Your floor has two parts:
- All-in cost per mile. Fuel, maintenance, tires, insurance, truck payment, permits and fixed costs, spread across every mile you drive, loaded and empty. If you don't have this yet, build your break-even rate per mile first.
- The profit per mile you need. Add it on top. That sum is your floor.
One more step catches most drivers. The broker pays you for loaded miles only, but you also drive the deadhead miles to the pickup. So divide your whole trip cost by loaded miles only:
Loaded-mile floor = (loaded + deadhead miles) x cost per mile, plus profit target, divided by loaded miles
Run the gap check: what the final offer really costs you
Example: say your all-in cost is $1.80 a mile and you want $0.30 a mile profit. The load is 500 loaded miles with 50 deadhead miles to get to it.
| Step | Math | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Trip cost | 550 miles x $1.80 | $990 |
| Profit target | 550 miles x $0.30 | $165 |
| Revenue needed | $990 + $165 | $1,155 |
| Floor per loaded mile | $1,155 / 500 | $2.31 |
Now the broker says $2.10 per loaded mile is the best they can do. That pays $1,050. You're $105 short of your profit target, and only $60 above your cost of $990. You'd run 550 miles to earn $60.
The gap check is one line: offer minus floor, times loaded miles. A negative number is the dollar amount you'd be paying to take the load.
Accept, ask, or decline: the final-offer check
Use this table every time you hear the line.
| If the offer is... | Do this |
|---|---|
| At or above your loaded-mile floor | Accept, or make one small ask that isn't rate (see below) |
| A little under your floor, and you're already empty in that area | Rerun the math with deadhead included. Take it only if the real number still clears your cost |
| Well under your floor | Decline politely and keep the door open |
| Backed by "that's the market rate" | Ask which lane rate they're using, then answer with your own lane data |
The middle row is where drivers lose money. A load "close to your floor" looks fine until the empty miles to the pickup come out of the margin.
Ask for something other than rate
A broker who won't move on rate often has room elsewhere. Drivers who only argue price miss the easier wins. Pick one:
- Detention terms. Get the free time and the hourly rate in writing. The detention pay guide shows how to calculate what you're owed.
- A faster payment term. Quick pay moves your cash up even if the rate stays put.
- A fuel surcharge line. Useful when diesel is moving.
Once you agree, check the rate confirmation before you sign, so what you asked for is actually on paper.
Treat a posted rate as an opening offer
TruckSmarter treats a posted rate as an opening offer, and that's the right way to hear "best I can do" too. It often means the first number, not the last. Your job is to find out which one it is without burning the relationship.
Bring a reason, not a feeling. Summar says pointing to market information that matches your requested rate makes brokers more likely to respond well. "It's too low" gives the broker an easy no. "This lane is running higher and my cost is $X" does not.
You also have something to sell. OTR Solutions says brokers pay more for carriers with proven on-time delivery and clean safety scores. Mention that only if it's true, and only once.
Use one industry number as backup, never as your floor
Sometimes a broker pushes back on your cost. An outside number helps. The American Transportation Research Institute's 2025 operational costs report puts average operating cost at $2.336 a mile, the highest in the report's history. Excluding fuel it's $1.854 a mile, up 4.2% from $1.779.
Example: say a broker offers $1,400 for a 600-mile load. That's about $2.33 a mile, right at the industry average cost, before any profit and before deadhead. You can say that out loud.
Two cautions keep you honest:
- These are fleet averages. They include a hired driver. As an owner-operator you can look closer to the owner-operator figure of 82.6 cents a mile before fuel, the average cost once driver pay and benefits come out. Your own number still wins.
- Tolls rose 13.2%, repair and maintenance 8.6%, and tires 6.4%, per the same coverage. If your cost per mile is from last year, it's too low.
Say the final no in four lines
Copy this and change the numbers:
- Acknowledge, then state your number. "I hear you. At that rate I'm under my cost on this lane. I need $2.31 a mile to make it work."
- Ask what else is flexible. "If the rate is firm, can you do something on detention or a quick-pay term?"
- Hold the line without heat. "I understand. I can't make that one work. Keep me in mind for the next one on this lane."
- Quote one number if they push back, then stop talking. "Industry cost data puts average operating cost above $2.30 a mile. At your number I'd be under that before I make a dollar."
Keep it short and calm. Frustration can cost you the next load from that broker, and the next load is the point of saying no politely.
Mistakes that turn a final offer into a bad week
| Mistake | What it costs |
|---|---|
| Not knowing your floor | You can't tell a real final offer from a bluff, so you take loads that barely cover costs |
| Leaving deadhead out | The offer looks like it clears your cost, but the empty miles eat the margin |
| Arguing without data | "Too low" is an easy no for the broker |
| Only asking for rate | You miss detention terms and payment speed |
| Showing frustration | You lose the next load from that broker |
When the load stays under your floor after one ask, walk away. Bestpass puts it plainly: being willing to decline loads that don't support your operation puts you in control of the negotiation.
Do this in the next ten minutes
Write your floor on a sticky note or the first line of your phone's notes: all-in cost per mile, plus the profit you need, with deadhead on a typical load worked in. Then you can answer "best I can do" with a number instead of a feeling.
Get the number before the broker calls
The script only works if the floor is right, and that comes down to doing the math the same way every time. HaulMath runs the freight math for owner-operators so you can check a load before you answer the broker. Try HaulMath
Common questions
- What do I say when a broker says that's the best they can do?
- Restate your number and ask what else is flexible: "At that rate I'm under my cost on this lane. I need $X. If the rate is firm, can you do something on detention or quick pay?" If nothing moves, decline politely and ask them to keep you in mind for the next load.
- Is "that's the best I can do" ever a bluff?
- It often means the first number, not the last, since a posted rate is usually an opening offer. You can't tell the difference unless you know your floor, so work that out before the call.
- Should I walk away from a load that's slightly under my rate?
- Rerun the math with deadhead miles included. If the real number still clears your cost and you have a reason to be in that area, it can be fine. If not, walk away.
- What can I ask for besides a higher rate?
- Detention terms, a faster payment term, or a fuel surcharge line. Get whatever you agree to onto the rate confirmation.
- Can I quote the industry average cost per mile to a broker?
- Yes, as backup. ATRI's 2025 report puts average operating cost at $2.336 a mile. It's a fleet average, so it supports your own cost per mile and doesn't replace it.
Run your own numbers
Free calculators for owner-operators: load profit, cost per mile, IFTA, per diem, and more. Every answer shows the math.